Womens Tsubo

Which of these four boots should I get? (With links?)?

I live in Boston where they heavily salt roads in winter, and I need a pair of leather boots to wear with black tights and winter dresses. Which of these should I do? Oh and btw my style is a kind of vintagey / Comfortable (I wear lots of sweaters and scarves in shades of gray, brown and red), and I'm pretty big and I am not with heels. THANK YOU for your opinion! Http: / / piperlime.gap.com / browse / product.do? Pid = 8215210021100 & cid = 51758 http://www.onlineshoes.com/womens-tsubo-baco-black-camouflauge-p_id191329 www.zappos.com/enzo-angiolini-zoot-black-leather?zfcTest=prodPage2:0 http:// http:// www.onlineshoes.com/womens-timberland-earthkeepers-granby-tall-zip-boot-black-p_id191656

I'm not a big fan of the former. The next two are pretty similar to me, but I prefer Tsubo Baco. They seem to have much more traction on the bottom of things which I'm sure will come handy when hiking through the streets of Boston in winter. The latter are cute too, but much more relaxed. Depending on your lifestyle (student and / or more casual vs. professional work, but I prefer a more relaxed dress code in your spare time), I think the Baco Tsubo could more easily move from a more casual look for a more professional look with dresses.